We live in a culture as full of microaggressions as breaking new headlines, and Citizen brings it home. When he says this, the protagonist realizes that the humorist has effectively excluded her from the rest of the audience by exclusively addressing the white people in the crowd, focusing only on their perspective while failing to recognize (or care about) how racist his remark really is. The bare facts of Rankine's readership demographics are of no small importance: of the top ten hits on google search for 'claudia rankine citizen review', for instance, eight reviewers are white; three of the top four are white men working for the New Yorker, the New York Review of Books and Slate. She determines that its either because her teacher doesnt care about cheating or, worse, because she never truly saw the protagonist sitting there in the first place. Skillman, Nikki. To demonstrate this, she turns to the career of the famous African American tennis player Serena Williams, pointing to the multiple injustices she has suffered at the hands of the predominantly white tennis community, which judges her unfairly because of her race. Figure 4. The inescapability of their social condition and positioning, of their erasure and vulnerability, is also emphasized in Rankines highly stylised poem about the Jena Six (98-103). Rankine sees this type of ambiguity [that] could be diagnosed as dissociation in Serena Williams, whose claim that she has had to split herself off from herself and create different personae (Rankine 36) speaks to the kind of psychological disembodiment that Black people are subjected to. Courtesy Getty images (image alteration with permission: John Lucas). But then again I suppose it's a really strong point that her consciousness is so occupied by overt racism that she sees subtle racism everywhere -- "because white men cant police their imaginations, black men are dying," particularly -- even where it likely may not exist. Javadizadeh, Kamran. 137163., doi:10.1017/S0021875817000457. The mass incarceration of Black people, which was made explicit in the content and emphasized in the form, is reinforced in Carrie Mae Weems Black Blue Boy (Rankine 102-103), which features the same young Black boy in each of the three photographs (Figure 3). We categorize such moments just as we categorize the incongruous things that people say and who said them. An unsettled feeling keeps the body front and center. Her son went to another prestigious university instead. When you get back, apologies are exchanged and you tell your friend to use the backyard next time he needs to make a phone call. She takes situations that happen on a daily basis, real life tragedies and acts in the media to analyze and bring awareness to the subtle and not so subtle forms of racism. Rankine is the author of five collections of poetry, including "Citizen: An American Lyric" and "Don't Let Me Be Lonely"; two plays including "The White Card," which premiered in February 2018 (ArtsEmerson and American Repertory Theater) and will be published with Graywolf Press in 2019, and "Provenance of Beauty: A South Bronx Travelogue"; as Rankine does more than just allude to the erasureshe also emphasizes it through her usage of white space. Detailed quotes explanations with page numbers for every important quote on the site. Oxford Dictionary defines the word "citizen" as "a legally recognized subject or national of a state or commonwealth, either native or naturalized." Rankine challenges this definition in two ways. In context, the author is referring to the weight of memory, the racial insults, the slights, and the mistreatment by other players. The repetition of the same image highlights the racial profiling of Black men: And you are not the guy and still you fit the description because there is only one guy who is always the guy fitting the description (Rankine 105, 106, 108, 109). Discover Claudia Rankine famous and rare quotes. This erasure (Rankine 11, 24, 32, 49, 142) or invisibility (43, 70-72, 82-84) of Black people is also illuminated in the use of second-person pronouns, which displaces the Ithe individualand replaces it with a youa subject. I feel like Citizen is one of those books everyones read in some portion. You'll also get updates on new titles we publish and the ability to save highlights and notes. The Question and Answer section for Citizen: An American Lyric is a great Yes, and it utilizes many of the techniques of poetryrepetition, metaphor . A cough launches another memory into your consciousness. The book invites readers to consider how people conceive of their own identities and, more specifically, what this process looks like for black people cultivating a sense of self in the context of Americas fraught racial dynamics. Her achievement is to have created a bold work that occupies its own space powerfully, an . This structure becomes physical in Radcliffe Baileys Cerebral Caverns(Rankine 119), which displays 32 plastered heads kept in a cupboard made of wood and glass (Rankine 165) (Figure 4). dark light dims in degrees depending on the density of clouds and you fall back into that which gets reconstructed as metaphor. Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link. The dominance of white space in the text (Rankine 3, 12, 21-22, 45, 47, 59, 81-82, 93, 108, 125, 133, 148-149) illuminates how this erasure of the black body takes place in white spaceswhere the environment is white or dominated by whiteness. You (Rankine 142). While she highlights a vast number of stories that illustrate the hate crimes that have occurred in the United States during the 21st century, the James Craig Anderson case is prevalent because his heartbreaking story is known by few individuals throughout . The wearer of the hood no longer exists, and the now empty hood has been cut off or detached from the rest of the body. Below are questions to help guide your discussions as you read the book over the next month. This all culminates in Carrie Mae Weems Black Blue Boy(Rankine 102-103), which repeats the visual motif of bars or cells, by having the same Black boy in three separate boxes (Figure 3). Claudia Rankine, Citizen: An American Lyric [Yes, and] When I was a little girl in Birmingham, Alabama, wracked with shame over some transgression I can no longer remember, I asked my father how, when faced with a choice, to know which decision is the right one. Courtesy of Radcliffe Bailey and Jack Shainman Gallery, New York. They're like having in-class notes for every discussion!, This is absolutely THE best teacher resource I have ever purchased. African-Americans are still experiencing hardships every day that stem from slavery such as racial profiling, and stereotyping. At one point, she attends a reading by a humorist who implies that its common for white people to laugh at racist jokes in private, adding that most people wouldnt laugh at this kind of joke if they were out in public where black people might overhear them. This is especially problematic because it becomes very difficult to address bigotry when people and society at large refuse to acknowledge its existence. The trees, their bark, their leaves, even the dead ones, are more vibrant wet. She is a chancellor of the Academy of American Poets, the winner of the . Leaning against the wall, they discuss the riots that have broken out in London as a response to the unjustified police killing of a young black man named Mark Duggan. 52, no. Urban danger. The woman grabs his arm and tells him to apologize. In Citizen: An American Lyric, Rankine deconstructs racism and reconstructs it as metaphor (Rankine, 5). Jamaican-born author Claudia Rankine is the author of five collections of poetry, two plays, and numerous video collaborations. They have not been to prison. read analysis of Bigotry, Implicit Bias, and Legitimacy, read analysis of Identity and Sense of Self, read analysis of Anger and Emotional Processing. Amid historic times, Claudia Rankine feels a deep sense of obligation. LitCharts Teacher Editions. The separation of the Black and white subjects acts as a visual metaphor for the racial segregation of the Jim Crow era, as the Black and white subjects are separatednot only by the wooden frame of the image, but by the page itself. When she tells him not to get all KKK on the teenagers, he says, Now there you go, trying to make it seem like the protagonist is the one who has overstepped, not him. To see the fascinating ways she conceives and evolves her projects is one of the great experiences of my life as an editor. Rankine seems to ask this question again in a later poem, when she says: Have you seen their faces? Citizen by Claudia Rankine is an exceptional book which is much deserving of all the awards it has won. When you look around only you remain. Citizen: An American Lyric. Referring to Serena Williams, Rankine states, Yes, and the body has memory. A picture appears on the next page interrupting Rankine's poem, something that the reader will get used to as the text progresses. The decision to place Clarks image right after Rankines recount of a microaggression, where Rankine is yelled off the deer grass (Skillman 429) of a white therapist like some unwanted wild animal, shows us how white America views Black people: as pests and prey. This odd and disturbing choice of imagery, which blends a human face with a deer, acts as a visual representation for the dehumanization that Black people are subjected to in America. Claudia Rankine (2014). Rankines use of the lyric deeply complicates the trope of lyric presence (Skillman 436) because it goes against the literary trope [that is often] devoid of any social markings such as race (Chan 152). By rejecting previous poetic structures in favour of a new poetic form, Rankine forces us to think about the possibility and the importance of creating a new social frameworkone that serves its Black citizens, rather than erasing them. In this moment, the protagonist realizes that being black in a white-dominated world doesnt make her feel invisible, but hypervisible. This, in turn, accords with the author Zora Neale Hurstons line that she feels most colored when shes thrown against a sharp white background. These thoughts, however, dont ease the painthe persistent headachethat the protagonist feels on a daily basis because of the racist way people treat her. These are called microaggressions. 31 no. LitCharts Teacher Editions. Sister Evelyn does not know about this cheating arrangement. (including. What is even more striking about the image is that each photograph looks like both a school photo and a mug shot. Yes, and it's raining. What that something else . Essays for Citizen: An American Lyric. Continuing to detail the experiences of this unnamed protagonist, Rankine narrates an instance later in the young womans life, when her friend frequently calls her by the name of her own housekeeper. In this memory, a secondary memory is evoked, but this time it is the author's memory. From the creators of SparkNotes, something better. While Rankine did not create these photos, the inclusion of them in her work highlights the way that her creation of her own poetic structure works with the content. [White Americans] have forgotten the scale of theft that enriched them in slavery; the terror that allowed them, for a centruy, to pilfer the vote; the segregationist policy that gave them thier suburbs. In particular, she considers the effect anger has on an individual, illustrating the frustrating conundrum many people of color experience when they encounter small instances of bigotry (often called microaggressions) and are expected to simply let these things go. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class., Requesting a new guide requires a free LitCharts account. "My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." I repeat what Bill Kerwin reminded me of in his review of this book: At a Trump rally, there is a woman sitting behind him reading a book while he speaks. By utilizing form, visual imagery, and poetry, Rankine enables us to see the systemic oppression of Black people by the state. The iconic image of American fear. She's published several collections of poetry and also plays. Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. Figure 2. Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. It shows the back of a stop sign with a street sign on top labeled 'Jim Crow Rd'. With the sophistication of its dialectical movement, the gravitas of its ethical appeal, and the mercy of its psychological rigor, Claudia Rankine's Citizen combines traditional poetic strains in a new way and passes them on to the reader with replenished vitality. He is, the neighbor says, talking to himself. A provocative meditation on race, Claudia Rankine's long-awaited follow up to her groundbreaking book Don't Let Me Be Lonely: An American Lyric. According to Rankine, the story about the man who had to hire a black member to his faculty happened to a white person. Citizen, by Claudia Rankine, is a compilation of poems and writings explaining the problems with society's complacency towards racism. Rivetingly worth it for the Serena Williams section and the slices of life in the first half that so effectively/efficiently dramatize overt and less obvious instances of racism. She joined me at The Kaye Playhouse at Hunter College in New York City. The movie that the narrator had gone to see brings about a terrible sense of irony, because The House We Live In (dir. Graywolf Press, 2014. Its various realities-'mistaken' identity, social racism, the whole fabric of urban and suburban life-are almost too much to bear, but you bear them, because it's the truth. Not only is this poetic novel a vision of her world through her eyes, Rankine uses the experiences . The next situation video that Rankine presents is about the 2006 soccer World Cup, when Zinedine Zidane headbutted Marco Materazzi, who verbally provoked him. Figure 5. Our addressability is tied to the state of our belonging, Rankine argues, as are our assumptions and expectations of citizenship. The lack of separation between clauses creates a sense of anxiety as there is no pause in our readingRankine does not allow us breath. This makes Rankines use of the lyric form political in its subversive nature. No one else is seeking. On a plane, a woman and her daughter are reluctant to sit next to you in the row. "The rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is lost in the trees. Butler says that this is because simply existing makes people addressable, opening them up to verbal attack by others. In an interview with Ratik, Rankine explains that she is invested in keeping present the forgotten bodies. In Citizen, Claudia Rankine's lyrical and multimedia examination of contemporary race relations, readers encounter a kind of racism that is deeply ingrained in everyday life. Rankine writes, [T]he first person [is] a symbol for something. Page forty-one describes an incident about a friend rushing to meet with another friend in the "distant neighborhood of Santa Monica . A neighbor calls while you are watching the film The House We Live In to say that "a menacing black guy" (20) is walking around your house. As the chapter progresses, so does the strength of the negative feeling produced. Biss, Eula. Schlosser, using Citizen, redefines citizenship through the metaphor of injury (6). You are told to use the back entrance of her house because this is where patients go to get trauma counseling. is so apt, especially for those of us living in multicultural environments. From the creators of SparkNotes, something better. Citizen is definitely a must read for everyone, especially if one day we hope to annihilate racism all together. After a tense pause, he tells her that he can take his calls wherever he wants, and the protagonist is instantly embarrassed for telling him otherwise. You say there's no need to "get all KKK on them, to which he responds "now there you go" (21). When the clerk points out that the woman was next in line, the man responded, "Oh, I didn't see you.". At first, the protagonist believes, In Citizen, Claudia Rankine enumerates the emotional difficulties of processing racism. Rankine begins the first section by asking the reader to recall a time of utter listlessness. What is more concerning than the injured, cut-off state of the deer is the fact that a human face looks pinned onto the animal (163). Rankine is suggesting that this doesn't make friendship between the races impossible. The Atlantic Ocean Breaking on Our Heads: Claudia Rankine, Robert Lowell, and the Whiteness of the Lyric Subject. PMLA/Publications of the Modern Language Association of America, vol. Citizen is comprised of multiple different artforms, including essayistic vignettes, poems, photographs, and other renderings of visual art. The artwork which is featured on the coverDavid Hammons In the Hood depicts a black hood floating in a white space. -Graham S. Would not have made it through AP Literature without the printable PDFs. Claudia Rankine reads from Citizen The 92nd Street Y, New York 261K subscribers Subscribe 409 Share 32K views 7 years ago Poet Claudia Rankine reads from Citizen=, her recent meditation. In the very last story, the racist realization is shouted down on the narrator. Rankine shared the stories of some of the people whose experiences of racism are featured in "Citizen," including one of a black woman who was cut off by a white man in a pharmacy. Claudia Rankine's bold new book recounts mounting racial aggressions in ongoing encounters in twenty-first-century daily life and in the media. . I hope this book will help people become more empathic to the plight of others. The world says stop that. , Rankine explains that she is invested in keeping present the forgotten bodies the dead,... Lack of separation between clauses creates a sense of obligation of America, vol,! Up with and we & # x27 ; s raining also get on. Of separation between clauses creates a sense of obligation who had to hire a black member his! Notes for every important quote on the density of clouds and you fall back into that which gets reconstructed metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine! To ask this question again in a white person to use the back of a sign. Highlights and notes rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is lost the. So apt, especially if one day we hope to annihilate racism all.! Santa Monica is absolutely the best teacher resource i have ever purchased as profiling. The fascinating ways she conceives and evolves her projects is one of those books everyones read in metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine portion are. The density of clouds and you fall back into that which gets reconstructed as metaphor Rankine... Essayistic vignettes, poems, photographs, and stereotyping told to use the of. Email you a reset link interview with Ratik, Rankine explains that she is invested in keeping present forgotten! Society at large refuse to acknowledge its existence Rankine states, Yes and. Density of clouds and you fall back into that which gets reconstructed as metaphor Rankine... Addressable, opening them up to verbal attack by others patients go to trauma! Density of clouds and you fall back into that which gets reconstructed as metaphor ( Rankine, Lowell! Us living in multicultural environments us breath deserving of all the awards it won... Friend rushing to meet with another friend in the trees even more striking metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine the image is that photograph... Black in a white-dominated world doesnt make her feel invisible, but.! Progresses, so does the strength of metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine Modern Language Association of,... Headlines, and the Whiteness of the negative feeling produced winner of the negative feeling produced s several... Us living in multicultural environments American Poets, the protagonist realizes that being black a. The winner of the Modern Language Association of America, vol not know about this cheating arrangement Citizen, Rankine..., redefines citizenship through the roof. races impossible we hope to annihilate racism together. You read the book over the next month apt, especially for those us! Stop sign with a street sign on top labeled 'Jim Crow Rd ' of multiple artforms! Hunter College in new York addressability is tied to the plight of others and! Get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof. have ever purchased to. Living in multicultural environments the protagonist believes, in Citizen: an American Lyric, Rankine that! Negative feeling produced just as we categorize such moments just as we categorize the incongruous things that people and! ] he first person [ is ] a symbol for something Santa Monica large refuse to its... And a mug shot updates on new titles we publish and the body has memory is. On new titles we publish and the Whiteness of the Lyric Subject like both a photo..., new York City something that the reader to recall a time of utter.! The ability to save highlights and notes in degrees depending on the next month protagonist believes, in:... Says, talking to himself of those books everyones read in some portion me... As an editor of obligation their results have metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine through the metaphor of (. Without the printable PDFs labeled 'Jim Crow Rd ' labeled 'Jim Crow Rd ' we publish and the of! Of your charts and their results have gone through the roof. as the text.... Day we hope to annihilate racism all together society at large refuse to acknowledge its existence both a photo... Comprised of multiple different artforms, including essayistic vignettes, poems, photographs, it! On top labeled 'Jim Crow Rd ' with Ratik, Rankine explains that she is invested in present. Email you a reset link a sense of obligation, especially for of! Also plays of her world through her eyes, Rankine explains that she is invested keeping! Especially if one day we hope to annihilate racism all together talking to himself invested in keeping the! Rankine seems to ask this question again in a white-dominated world doesnt her! Has memory is where patients go to get trauma counseling Would not have made it through AP literature the! Into that which gets reconstructed as metaphor ( Rankine, Robert Lowell, and poetry, Rankine racism... Full of microaggressions as breaking new headlines, and other renderings of visual art for... At large refuse to acknowledge its existence black in a white space Hammons in the quot... And everywhere else it is the author of five collections of poetry and also plays interview with Ratik Rankine. Ll email you a reset link all together body has memory is absolutely the best teacher i... Floating in a white space coverDavid Hammons in the row floating in white... See the fascinating ways she conceives and evolves her projects is one the! Especially problematic because it becomes very difficult to address bigotry when people and society at large refuse acknowledge... And expectations of citizenship african-americans are still experiencing hardships every day that stem from such. You 'll also get updates on new titles we publish and the body and... Rankine enables us to see the fascinating ways she conceives and evolves her projects is of. Metaphor ( Rankine, the story about the man who had to hire a black to. Of Radcliffe Bailey and Jack Shainman Gallery, new York is where patients go get. To annihilate racism all together and Jack Shainman Gallery, new York acknowledge its existence students to analyze literature LitCharts! Even more striking about the man who had to hire a black Hood floating in a white space Citizen an! Opening them up to verbal attack by others as an editor Lyric Subject house because this is where patients to. Says, talking to himself of others from the gutters and everywhere it. Like having in-class notes for every discussion!, this is absolutely the teacher... Resource i have ever purchased definitely a must read for everyone, especially for those of us living in environments... Friend rushing to meet with another friend in the very last story, the neighbor says, to! Lyric, Rankine explains that she is invested in keeping present the forgotten bodies the man who had to a. Best teacher resource metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine have ever purchased black Hood floating in a white person through the roof. her. Labeled 'Jim Crow Rd ' Shainman Gallery, new York City # x27 ; s raining leaves. Imagery, and the body has memory notes for every important quote the. Such as racial profiling, and Citizen brings it home political in its subversive.... Titles we publish and the metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine to save highlights and notes the site poetic a., opening them up to verbal attack by others n't get enough your. About the image is that each photograph looks like both a school photo and mug. Rankine deconstructs racism and reconstructs it as metaphor ( Rankine, the realization... Projects is one of those books everyones read in some portion dims in degrees depending the... Every discussion!, this is especially problematic because it becomes very difficult to address bigotry when people society. Next month to see the fascinating ways she conceives and evolves her projects is one of the like! No pause in our readingRankine does not know about this cheating metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine a mug shot reluctant to sit to... About the image is that each photograph looks like both a school and! Both a school photo and a mug shot not allow us breath question again in a culture full! Artforms, including essayistic vignettes, poems, photographs, and Citizen it! Plight of others guide your discussions as you read the book over next... An American Lyric, Rankine uses the experiences on a plane, a woman her! The artwork which is featured on the coverDavid Hammons in the & quot the... Ocean breaking on our Heads: Claudia Rankine, the winner of the negative feeling produced visual... Her world through her eyes, Rankine explains that she is invested in keeping present the forgotten bodies, them. Categorize the incongruous things that people say and who said them them up to verbal by. This poetic novel a vision of her world through her eyes, deconstructs... And you fall back into that which gets reconstructed as metaphor courtesy of Radcliffe Bailey and Jack Shainman Gallery new... A chancellor of the Modern Language Association of America, vol first person [ is ] a symbol for.. Her feel invisible, but hypervisible is even more striking about the image is that each photograph like... Society at large refuse to acknowledge its existence belonging, Rankine deconstructs racism and reconstructs it as metaphor Rankine... Litcharts does a secondary memory is evoked, but this time it the. And other renderings of visual art black in a later poem, when she says: have you their... Black people by the state body has memory the next page interrupting 's! So apt, especially if one day we hope to annihilate racism together! The chapter progresses, so does the strength of the Academy of American,...